Never thought I'd spend 45 minutes staring at grout color samples, but here we are! 😅 I'm doing white subway tile and can't decide between white, light gray, or dark gray grout.

White grout:
+ Seamless clean look
- Shows dirt, needs more cleaning

Light gray:
+ More forgiving than white
- Might look dingy?

Dark gray (charcoal):
+ Modern contrasting look
+ Hides dirt
- Too trendy? Will I hate it in 5 years?

Help me overthinking folks - what did you choose and how do you feel about it now? My contractor needs an answer tomorrow and I literally cannot decide. Why is this the hardest decision?!